How shoppers are finding value amid economic pressures this holiday season

Amber Reese, Bealls Inc.

The 2026 holiday season is rapidly approaching, and Americans are facing economic pressures from inflation, rising costs, and the uncertain economy. Across the country, holiday decorations adorn neighborhoods, festive music plays over radio stations, and shoppers carefully curate their shopping lists not only to stay within their budgets but also to find what will bring the most value.

Many holiday shoppers will be searching for the perfect gifts for family and friends while wanting to maximize their shopping experience. They still want the satisfaction of finding the right gift, the surprise of discovering something unexpected, and the pleasure of giving something that feels thoughtful, all while feeling like they achieved a sense of value. Bealls Inc. explains why off-price shopping may be the best route for holiday shoppers looking to find the most value out of their yearly gift-giving traditions.

Value is about more than price

The holiday season is supposed to be the most wonderful time of the year. However, anxieties regarding personal finances and affordability can easily make it one of the most economically stressful times of the year. According to The National Retail Federation’s October 2026 Holiday Consumer Survey, 56% of holiday shoppers say the state of the economy will affect their holiday spending plans this year. When shoppers may be asking themselves if their bills will still be affordable alongside their holiday shopping lists, it’s unsurprising that getting the most value out of their shopping is a priority.

Holiday shopping won’t disappear this year, but the shoppers behind those gifts may be approaching with caution, concern, and considerable regards to the “perceived value” — of both the item itself and the overall shopping experience. This upcoming holiday season, before making a purchase and crossing a name off the “nice” list, shoppers may be asking themselves questions like: Is this gift worth its cost? Is this gift of good value? Has shopping in this store been a satisfying experience?

As shoppers begin to question the perceived value of their purchases and experiences, they are asserting their own wants too. NRF also found that 56% of shoppers stated the most important factor is the price, 51% emphasized their desire for product quality, and 46% expressed that they want to see a wide variety of merchandise. When it appears as if every aspect of daily life is getting more expensive every day, shoppers want greater confidence that what they’re buying is worth it and what they’re going through to make that purchase is worth it too.

Economic pressure is making shoppers more deliberate

Shoppers are now prioritizing new areas that may be more financially suitable for them and their budgets. In their October 2026 survey, TruRating found that while shoppers are experiencing economic stress near the holiday season, they are not choosing to trade down their purchases, but instead, they are adjusting their behaviors. They’re looking to protect what matters to them — value — by changing their shopping routines, frequency of buying, and spending priorities. They are less interested in the idea of getting the biggest discount on a purchase and instead focused on the presentation of the item in-store, if it’s a unique, elevated brand, and the item’s quality — all of which can enhance the perceived value.

Research from Forrester, “Predictions: 2027 Retail”, also highlights changes in spending patterns, pointing out the market shift to shoppers who are prioritizing affordability and value more than before. Holiday shoppers are likely to be more thoughtful and selective in their purchases this year. To help guide this value-conscious shopper, retailers may aim to ensure that a purchase is not just a transaction but also delivers both discovery and personal significance. Think of the difference between finding an inexpensive item that would suffice as a gift, versus discovering a hot, new fragrance, or a beautiful, boxed piece of jewelry, or a ready-to-be-gifted multipiece set, all at an affordable price. There can be an element of surprise and fun that comes with searching for the perfect gift. It’s all about the thrill of the hunt for some holiday shoppers, and retailers may want to accommodate this.

There is also a change in consumers’ spending patterns; what they are willing to spend money on and where they place their priorities in a time of hardship. Retailers are placing higher price tags on clothing made entirely of materials that may not be worth the customers’ value. A study on garment durability and longevity compared to its price point has discovered that there is no indication that higher price equals higher quality. As production and manufacturing education becomes more widespread, shoppers are now questioning if a product is truly worth the amount they are asked to pay.

Seeing merchandise in a store matters

This holiday season is expected to see the lowest number of online shoppers since 2015, with only 52% reporting that they will complete their gift list online, according to NRF. While the online shopping fatigue may not be entirely shocking, the same NRF survey cites three specific reasons why brick-and-mortar will be preferred this year.

First, shoppers are expressing their desire to physically see and evaluate their purchase before making the final decision. This gives them a chance to ask whether the product is worth the cost and what value they’ll be getting out of it. Next, they want a more thoughtful shopping experience; adding insight into purchases not only increases their value but makes gift-giving more personal and meaningful.

Finally, people are choosing to shop in stores this year to fully experience the holiday ambiance that stores produce; an experience that is hard to experience through a screen. Shoppers want a true shopping experience with face-to-face customer service, clean, organized aisles, and efficient checkout lanes.

Off-Price Shopping — The Potential Answer to the Equation

One route that holiday shoppers can take to combat this stress is through off-price shopping. With an expected $233 billion growth over the next 11 years, according to a recent study from Reputation Partners, off-price retailers are an important piece of the puzzle of getting the most value out of holiday shopping. Shoppers still want what they know, brands they trust, and quality they can feel, but are more conscious about the “worth” of these products.

Off-price retailers often have an exceptional understanding of shoppers’ preferences. They place the comparison aspect in front of shoppers, who don’t have to question whether they’ll miss a great deal or whether the item might go on sale in the next week. Off-price retailers are also fast at matching trends and flipping their inventory to help shoppers get something unexpected at a great value

Shopping is an overall experience, and holiday shopping should be filled with meaning, purpose, and joy. In a time of economic instability, shoppers can prioritize their own meaning of value. Whether it means affordability, experience, convenience, or quality, understanding what is important to your shopping needs can make this holiday shopping experience much simpler.